Convicted woman released
By Lynn Paltrow, JD Executive Director, National Advocates for Pregnant Women
On November 19, 2008, after serving only one year from the date of sentencing, Theresa Lee Hernandez was released from prison.
Ms. Hernandez was arrested in 2004 and charged with first-degree murder (a crime with a potential penalty of 25 years-to-life imprisonment) and second-degree murder for having suffered a stillbirth. The state of Oklahoma claimed — without any scientific basis — that the stillbirth was caused by her methamphetamine use.
In 2007, as her case approached trial, national and state-based organizations, advocates and experts organized, educated and spoke out against the prosecution. These efforts were instrumental in helping Ms. Hernandez avoid a life sentence and in enabling her counsel, Robin Shellow and Jim Rowan, to negotiate a plea bargain. That plea, entered last November, resulted in a sentence of 15 years, to be revisited after Ms. Hernandez served one year in prison.
As the Tulsa World reported: “Theresa Lee Hernandez, 31, appeared before Judge Virgil Black for a sentencing modification hearing. At the request of prosecutors, Black agreed to “suspend the remainder of her sentence and ordered her released from custody.” Ms. Hernandez will go to a private treatment program for 90 days and will be on probation for 10 years.
Just a week before Ms. Hernandez’s November 19 release, the second of two public forums regarding pregnancy, parenting and drug use was held. This forum, held at the Integris Baptist Medical Center in Oklahoma City, was co-sponsored by the local chapters of the National Association of Social Workers and of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the YWCA Oklahoma City, and Oklahoma State University’s Gender and Women’s Studies program. The panel discussion included local experts, doctors Eli Reshef and Dana Stone, and continued a conversation that drew upon evidence-based research concerning pregnancy, parenting and drug use. This conversation had begun at an Oklahoma forum one year earlier, in anticipation of Ms. Hernandez’s sentencing.
Ms. Hernandez’ release was not typical. Even in cases where a conviction is completely overturned, prisoners are almost always returned to prison for processing – something that can take weeks or even months - before they are finally released. In Ms. Hernandez’ case, the judge ordered that her handcuffs be removed right in the courtroom and that she be allowed to leave straight from the courthouse to her awaiting family and friends.
The Channel 9 news story, “Freed from Prison,” began by noting that “The case created a firestorm with doctors and women’s advocates who rallied to the woman’s side.”
Comments off

